Abubacarr Jawara Wins Court Approval to Present Recordings in Rebuttal

Abubacarr Jawara
Abubacarr Jawara has been allowed to present audio recordings in rebuttal after the defence closed its case, according to a ruling by High Court Justice Ebrima Jaiteh. The recordings have not yet been admitted as evidence, and the judge stressed that their authenticity and relevance still need to be established. Jawara’s lawyer, I. Drameh, applied orally under the court rules, saying the recordings could challenge answers given by second defendant Saihou Drammeh during cross-examination. Drammeh’s lawyer, Badou S. M. Conteh, objected, arguing that Jawara should not be able to add evidence after both sides had closed their cases. Counsel for first defendant Kaddijah Kebbeh did not oppose the application. Justice Jaiteh said the rules allow a party to respond to evidence presented by the opposing side, but rebuttal cannot be used to repair gaps in a case or dispute answers on matters that are merely incidental. Citing earlier decisions, he explained that such evidence may be allowed when it addresses material points raised by the defence. The judge also noted that the recordings had not been tendered, examined or authenticated. His decision therefore does not establish that Drammeh gave false testimony or that the recordings contradict him. Any proposed evidence will remain subject to the applicable rules of admissibility. To protect the defendants’ ability to respond, Jawara must provide complete copies to both defendants before the next hearing and file an identical copy with the Registrar. He must also supply a schedule identifying the excerpts he intends to rely on and the testimony each is meant to answer. At the hearing, Jawara will have to lay the proper foundation through a competent witness and establish relevance, authenticity and admissibility. The judge said the defendants may challenge the material, and that advance disclosure and cross-examination can help address any unfairness. The ruling grants permission to try to introduce the recordings—not a finding that they are genuine or decisive.
Source ↗