Angela Constance Defends Grampian Hospitals as Surgeon’s Allegations Raise Questions

Scotland’s Health Secretary, Angela Constance, has insisted that two hospitals in NHS Grampian are safe, despite a surgeon’s grave allegations about patient care and avoidable deaths. Speaking on BBC Radio Scotland’s Breakfast programme, Constance said she wanted immediate improvements as well as changes that would last.
The dispute centres on Dr Mohammed Meer Habib, a surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, who says a review commissioned by NHS Grampian examined 45 liver and pancreatic surgery cases. According to the findings he shared, 19 of the 31 patients who died between 2015 and 2021 had experienced avoidable deaths. Habib has also argued that hundreds of patients may have suffered significant harm or avoidable deaths and called for a corporate homicide investigation into the health board.
Constance said a specialist team had been sent to NHS Grampian to provide intensive support, including help for the board’s new chair and incoming officials. She said clinical governance needed proper oversight and scrutiny, alongside practical support. Her comments followed a Healthcare Improvement Scotland report that identified serious weaknesses in leadership and medical workforce management across the board’s acute services.
Habib has said he contacted Police Scotland about the deaths in 2024 and wrote to the Lord Advocate the following year. He also says he raised his concerns with senior Scottish Government figures on several occasions. Police Scotland confirmed it was investigating a report received in 2024, with inquiries underway and a report due to be submitted to the Procurator Fiscal.
Asked why she had only learned of Habib’s correspondence on Thursday, Constance said it was current practice for detailed correspondence from individuals to be handled through established channels. She maintained that action was needed at the hospitals, while the surgeon’s claims and the police inquiry continue to draw attention to the board’s record.
Source ↗