Azruddin Mohamed remains in custody after High Court rejects bail challenge

Azruddin Mohamed will remain on remand after the High Court dismissed his challenge to the refusal of bail, according to the ruling. Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif rejected his application for judicial review of Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’s decision in a cybercrime case.
The judge stressed that the court was not hearing the bail application again. Its task was to decide whether the magistrate had used her discretion lawfully, followed the right legal principles and based the decision on a sound assessment of risk. Mohamed had to show a reviewable error for the High Court to step in.
Chandra-Hanif said a superior court should not lightly replace a magistrate’s judgment with its own. At the same time, she cautioned that detention cannot rest on unsupported assertions: there must be a rational, factual basis for finding that a legal ground to refuse bail exists. Simply repeating the language of the Bail Act, she said, is not enough.
The ruling also addressed the balance between a person’s liberty and presumption of innocence, and the public interest in preventing further offending and protecting the justice system. Bail decisions often come early in a case, before a trial or formal evidence-taking, and the judge said they do not automatically require witnesses to testify under oath.
Pending allegations may be considered when assessing prospective risk if there is an adequate factual foundation, the court said. They must not be treated as proof that Mohamed is guilty. He remains presumed innocent unless the charges are established.
The judge further distinguished the alleged risk of future offending from concerns about witness intimidation or interference with the administration of justice. Any concern about interference, the ruling indicated, must likewise be supported by relevant material. The High Court’s decision leaves the magistrate’s refusal of bail in place, and Mohamed remains in custody while the case proceeds.
Source ↗