Jilly Cooper’s Estate Faces Plagiarism Allegations Over Early Novel

Jilly Cooper
The estate of late novelist Jilly Cooper is facing possible legal action after a report alleged that her 1978 book Prudence copied material from two earlier works. The claims were published by The Observer, which said it compared passages in Cooper’s novel with Cyra McFadden’s The Serial, released in 1977, and Josephine Tey’s 1948 book The Franchise Affair. According to the report, the comparison identified 35 passages allegedly taken from The Serial. It said that dialogue spoken by Berenice, an American feminist character in Prudence, closely echoed lines attributed to a character named Kate in McFadden’s novel. The Observer described the similarities as appearing extensive and deliberate. These remain allegations, not a legal finding. McFadden died in 2024. Her daughter, Cyra, told the publication she was considering legal options, saying she was angered by the prospect that her mother’s work may have been taken. She also said she hoped Cooper’s other books would be scrutinised to determine whether similar material appeared elsewhere. Cooper, who died in October at 88 after a fall at her Gloucestershire home, was known for novels about Britain’s upper classes, including Riders, Rivals and Polo. Her 2024 damehood and the recent return of the television adaptation of Rivals to Disney+ have kept her work in the public eye. Because Cooper is no longer alive, any potential claim could not be brought against her personally. The report said her estate and publishers might face action over possible copyright infringement if the allegations are substantiated. The Telegraph noted that it could find no previous UK case of this kind involving a deceased author’s work. No court ruling or response from the estate is included in the account.
Source ↗