Strictly fans accuse Motsi Mabuse of belittling contestants after harsh feedback

Strictly Come Dancing viewers have accused judge Motsi Mabuse and her fellow panellists of being unnecessarily harsh during the programme’s fifth live show, with some saying that honest criticism crossed into belittling contestants. The reaction followed a night of blunt assessments and lower-than-expected marks, while viewers were also divided over the show’s presenting team.
Mabuse drew particular criticism for her comments to Lawrence Robb and dance partner Jowita Przystał after their Jive to “The Rockafeller Skank.” She told them the routine had not been their best and urged them to return to class and practise harder. Some viewers objected to the tone, with one social-media user saying the judges could be honest without being cruel. Others questioned why Mabuse seemed so negative during the show.
The comments came amid wider frustration about the panel’s approach. Viewers remarked that the judges appeared more severe than in previous weeks, while some complained about low scores for Robb. Others defended the feedback, suggesting the panel might simply be marking more strictly early in the competition. The response was not unanimous: fans also praised the judges’ honesty, with debate continuing online after the broadcast.
The presenting line-up also prompted mixed reactions. Emma Willis, Josh Widdicombe and Johannes Radebe have taken over the live show following the departure of Claudia Winkleman and Tess Daly. Some viewers said Willis had settled comfortably into the role, while others argued that the presenters should be split between the main stage, the contestants and backstage coverage. Several fans called for changes to the arrangement, and one said Widdicombe seemed uncomfortable beside Willis.
The article reports that the audience response was divided on both the judges’ feedback and the presenting format. Strictly’s fifth live episode therefore left viewers debating not just the dances, but whether the show’s criticism and on-screen hosting were working for them.
Source ↗