Andy Burnham’s Benefits Comments Leave Labour’s Youth Plan Facing Fresh Questions

Andy Burnham has drawn attention to a possible gap between his assurances about a proposed youth benefits overhaul and warnings from the plan’s author that some young people could receive less money in the short term. His remarks have added to questions about how Labour intends to reshape support for 16- to 24-year-olds classified as not in education, employment or training.
Speaking to The Times, Burnham said that if the plan worked, he would do everything he could to help ensure that no young person “loses out from a cash point of view”. In another interview, he said the proposals would not mean people had to lose money. Downing Street later said he meant that young people who lost access to benefits might not ultimately be worse off because they could move into work.
But Alan Milburn, the former Cabinet minister who produced the proposals, gave a more qualified account. In comments to Sky News, he said some people would receive less in the short term. Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said Burnham had been making the broader point that the reforms should give people a better life.
Milburn’s ten-year plan aims to halve the share of young people who are not in education, employment or training. It proposes changing the benefits system to save £3.6 billion a year and redirecting funding towards helping young people find work or training. One suggested “youth allowance” could replace the health element of Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment for people aged 16 to 24.
The proposals have already unsettled some Labour MPs. Conservatives have backed efforts to reduce the number of young people outside work and education, while questioning the scale of the state’s role and calling for tougher welfare cuts. Burnham has also suggested that the plan’s approach could be extended across age groups.
Milburn said his review did not cover people over 25, although he argued that some of its design features could be applied to older claimants. He urged the Government to bring forward separate proposals for a reformed welfare system for them. The dispute leaves a key question hanging over the plan: how far its promise of better opportunities can be reconciled with the prospect of some claimants receiving less in the short term.
Source ↗